

Literary Fiction · Reviewed by Vic Books Team
Ishiguro’s butler narrates a life of small, perfect duties while love and history pass outside the window; the novel is quietly devastating but not always gripping.
| Title | The Remains of the Day |
| Author | Kazuo Ishiguro |
| Publisher | Knopf |
| Published | 1989 |
| Pages | 245 |
| ISBN | 0394573439 |
| Our Rating | ★★★★★ 4/5 |
In 1956, Stevens, an ageing English butler working for an American owner of Darlington Hall, takes a rare motoring holiday to the West Country. His stated reason is professional: a former housekeeper, Miss Kenton, has written a letter that hints she might return to work, and the house is short-staffed.
The real reason, which he cannot say, sits underneath: Miss Kenton is the woman he worked beside for years and never reached for. As he drives through Salisbury, Taunton and Weymouth, he keeps slipping back into the interwar past at Darlington Hall. There he served Lord Darlington through unofficial conferences, rising Nazi guests, and the small daily rituals of silver, staff plans and cracked china.
The novel opens a double question: will Stevens see Miss Kenton again, and will he admit what his dignity has cost him?
The book reaches for something harder than a road trip plot: it wants you to live inside a man who has chosen restraint so completely that he cannot name grief, attraction, or moral doubt. It is promising not drama but the slow recognition that the narrator is lying to himself, and that you must do the feeling he refuses.
That is a promise worth making because it can produce genuine ache when the mask slips. But it is also a risk: the whole book depends on Stevens, and if you tire of him, it has nowhere else to go. Mostly it succeeds because Stevens is not a puzzle to decode; he is a person you gradually pity and sometimes flinch at.
Reading this book feels like being buttonholed by a very polite man who explains a simple errand as if it were a state paper.
Early on he says, “The idea of such a journey came about, I should point out, from a most kind suggestion put to me by Mr Farraday himself one afternoon almost a fortnight ago, when I had been dusting the portraits in the library.” That is funny and a little claustrophobic; you get the sense he would rather itemise the library than say he wants to see someone.
The book is often like that: the surface is cool, formal and precise, while the pressure underneath makes you turn pages.
The pace does not move in a straight line. The present-day journey is brief and quiet, while the past often breaks in and takes over. Some of those memory scenes have real grip: the father’s collapse during a grand conference, the argument about two Jewish maids, the conversation where Miss Kenton tells Stevens she might marry.
In the pantry scene, Stevens remembers, “All I can say is that everything around us suddenly became very still; it was my impression that Miss Kenton’s manner also underwent a sudden change; there was a strange seriousness in her expression, and it struck me she seemed almost frightened.” Reading that is like watching two people nearly step toward each other and then withdraw into their roles.
Miss Kenton feels real because she pushes back against Stevens; the father feels real because he will not admit his weakness; some of the political guests remain names.
Time passes strangely. For every charged scene, a long stretch follows where Stevens explains conference logistics or the history of silver polish, and the present-day trip stalls. But the book is not cold; it is warm in the way embarrassment is warm. It is funny in small, precise moments, and it is bruising when he refuses to go to his dying father.
This book loses people in the middle. After the father’s death, Stevens swerves into a long argument about what makes a great butler; it is repetitive, and the book has already shown the answer through his actions.
The 1923 conference material also sags: German envoys, French delegates and off-the-record guests arrive as names rather than scenes, and the novel reads like a cautious memoir for several stretches. Worse, when Stevens defends Lord Darlington against the charge of being taken in by Ribbentrop, the book says the same thing several times until you want it to stop arguing and show the next moment of living pain.
Some readers will put it down before the final third, which is a pity because the Miss Kenton reunion gives the book back its ache.
This is for someone who has worked under a boss they half-admired and never contradicted; Stevens will feel horribly familiar. It is also for readers who like fiction about self-deception, loyalty to the wrong cause, and what two people can fail to say over decades. It will lose anyone who needs a plot that moves forward, because much of the novel is circling inside the same regrets.
If you liked Julian Barnes’s The Sense of an Ending, try this; it is quieter, but it leaves the same slow bruise.
This is a patient, quietly devastating novel about the difference between a spotless silver service and a lived life. I rate it 4/5. Buy it if you have ever stayed too long in a role that asked you to become smaller, and want a book that shows you the bill.
Stevens will not ask for sympathy, and that is exactly why he earns it; the final conversation on the pier gives the book its honest, unconsoling last word.
VERDICT: buy

Vic Books has been part of New Zealand reading since 1975. The Wellington shop closed in 2023, and the doors moved online — same love of books, now a place to find your next great read and talk about it.


