The cryptocurrency landscape has evolved dramatically since Bitcoin first appeared in 2009. What began as an obscure digital experiment has transformed into a trillion-dollar market that’s captured the imagination of investors worldwide. But despite its prominence in financial discussions, a fundamental question remains: is cryptocurrency a legitimate investment opportunity or merely an elaborate con? As Kiwis increasingly explore digital assets, understanding the nuances of this question has never been more important.
Before diving into whether cryptocurrencies constitute smart investments or clever scams, it’s worth establishing what they actually are. At their core, cryptocurrencies are digital or virtual currencies secured by cryptography, making them theoretically immune to counterfeiting or double-spending. Most cryptocurrencies operate on decentralised networks based on blockchain technology—essentially distributed ledgers enforced by a network of computers.
Bitcoin remains the most recognised cryptocurrency, but thousands of alternatives (often called “altcoins”) exist, each with unique features and purposes. Ethereum, for instance, introduced smart contracts that execute automatically when certain conditions are met. Others focus on privacy, transaction speed, or specific industry applications.
This technological foundation is what proponents point to when arguing for cryptocurrency’s legitimacy. The blockchain, they contend, represents a revolutionary approach to recording transactions without requiring trusted third parties like banks or payment processors. This innovation alone, they suggest, gives cryptocurrencies inherent value.
Those who view cryptocurrency as a legitimate investment typically highlight several compelling arguments. First is the potential for extraordinary returns. Early Bitcoin adopters who held their investments have seen returns that dwarf those of traditional assets. A $1,000 investment in Bitcoin in 2010 would be worth millions today—a performance unmatched by any conventional investment vehicle.
Second is the concept of cryptocurrency as “digital gold” or a hedge against inflation. With a capped supply of 21 million coins, Bitcoin in particular has been positioned as a store of value immune to the money-printing policies that can devalue traditional currencies. This narrative gained significant traction during the COVID-19 pandemic, when governments worldwide implemented unprecedented monetary stimulus.
Third is the institutional adoption we’ve witnessed in recent years. Major companies like PayPal now allow cryptocurrency transactions, established financial institutions offer crypto custody services, and some publicly traded companies have added Bitcoin to their balance sheets. Here in New Zealand, the Financial Markets Authority now regulates cryptocurrency exchanges, lending a degree of legitimacy to the sector.
Finally, there’s the argument that blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies represent the future of finance—what enthusiasts call “Web3” or decentralised finance (DeFi). By investing now, proponents argue, you’re getting in early on a technological revolution comparable to the early internet.
Critics, however, present equally compelling arguments against viewing cryptocurrencies as legitimate investments. First and foremost is their extreme volatility. Bitcoin’s price has experienced multiple boom-and-bust cycles, with price drops of more than 80% not uncommon. This volatility makes cryptocurrencies unsuitable for risk-averse investors or those with short time horizons.
Then there’s the environmental concern. Bitcoin’s “proof-of-work” consensus mechanism requires enormous computing power, resulting in significant energy consumption. While defenders point to renewable energy usage and newer, more efficient protocols, the environmental critique remains valid for many cryptocurrencies.
The regulatory uncertainty surrounding cryptocurrencies also gives pause to traditional investors. While countries like El Salvador have embraced Bitcoin as legal tender, others have implemented partial or complete bans. New Zealand’s regulatory approach has been relatively measured, with the Inland Revenue Department issuing guidance on crypto taxation, but the global regulatory landscape remains fragmented and unpredictable.
Perhaps most damning is the prevalence of scams, fraud, and market manipulation in the cryptocurrency space. Pump-and-dump schemes, where influencers artificially inflate prices before selling their holdings, are common. According to reports from CERT NZ and the New Zealand Police, New Zealanders have lost millions to cryptocurrency scams in recent years, though exact figures vary by source and reporting methodology. These losses highlight the very real risks in this market.
Critics also question the fundamental value proposition of many cryptocurrencies. Unlike stocks, which represent ownership in companies that produce goods or services, or bonds, which generate interest payments, most cryptocurrencies don’t produce cash flow. Their value depends entirely on what someone else will pay for them in the future—what economists call the “greater fool theory.”
Perhaps the most reasonable position lies somewhere in the middle. Cryptocurrency might be better understood not as a traditional investment nor as an outright con, but as a highly speculative asset class with unique characteristics.
Viewing cryptocurrencies through this lens acknowledges both their potential upside and substantial risks. It suggests that while cryptocurrencies may have a place in some portfolios, that place should be proportional to one’s risk tolerance and understanding of the technology.
Many financial advisors in New Zealand recommend that, if investing in cryptocurrencies at all, clients should limit their exposure to no more than 5% of their overall portfolio. This approach treats cryptocurrency as a “moonshot” investment—one that could potentially deliver outsized returns but could also go to zero.
It’s also worth distinguishing between different cryptocurrencies. While Bitcoin has demonstrated staying power over more than a decade, many smaller projects have disappeared entirely, taking investors’ money with them. The distinction between established cryptocurrencies and unproven newcomers is crucial.
For Kiwi investors considering cryptocurrency, education remains paramount. Understanding blockchain technology, the specific value proposition of any cryptocurrency you’re considering, and the regulatory environment can help distinguish between legitimate opportunities and potential scams.
The cryptocurrency debate isn’t likely to be resolved anytime soon. What seems clear, however, is that digital assets in some form will continue to be part of the financial landscape. Whether they ultimately prove to be transformative investments or cautionary tales of financial mania will depend on how the technology evolves, how regulations develop, and how the market matures.
For now, approaching cryptocurrency with a combination of curiosity, caution, and critical thinking may be the wisest course—neither dismissing it entirely as a con nor embracing it uncritically as the future of finance.
This article is proudly brought to you by the New Zealand Knowledge Collective. We bring together expert insights and practical wisdom for informed living in today’s world. Through our network of Kiwi specialists and evidence-based resources, we’re dedicated to enhancing your knowledge journey across Aotearoa and beyond. Explore our latest posts and stay informed with the best in Books, Travel, Online Education, Personal Finance & Investment, Technology, and Home & Interior Design!
